Conferences Resources Cornhill Proclaimer
Home About Contact My PT

Proclaimer Blog

The leadership tension

May 10, 2016

Adrian Reynolds

FacebookXEmail

I love the sport of cycling, whether it’s on the track or road. And I’ve particularly enjoyed the recent success of the Great Britain team, which means I have some mixed feelings about the departure of the senior British coach, Shane Shutton (reported here in the Guardian). For the record, he denies the allegations (of bullying, sexism and other isms). He is also, however, a rather driven man, somewhat abrasive at times. But, first under David Brailsford, and now alone, there is no doubt he has overseen something of a transformation in British cycling, especially track cycling.

So the media response this weekend is not unexpected – we will win fewer medals, but be nicer with it. The team will be a bit more PC, but less aggressive in the saddle. Whether these speculations turn out to be true or not, those on the inside believe that – in general terms at least – this is the way it will go. There is a tension between niceness and aggressiveness. Many top coaches are bullies.

There are exceptions of course. But in the short term, the way to get the most out of people is to beat them up. In a previous life, I spent a secondment at the Serious Fraud Office investigating Robert Maxwell, and then worked for a short time for Mohammed Al Fayed so I know something about larger-than-life bosses and the atmosphere they create.

As always, of course, the church is in danger of imitating the world, and we convince ourselves that good leadership means strong leadership which means (although we never call it this) being a bully. For the record, I have no one in mind, but it is a truism that, in the short term, such leadership will do churches an apparent good. There will be an atmosphere of fear, but we won’t call it that. We’ll call it strong, masculine, even godly.

Conversely, the Bible model for leadership is gentleness and compassion. Such qualities are not to be confused with firmness and conviction (something I sometimes get muddled, I must confess). Nevertheless, we must not swallow the world’s lie that allows bullying into the church and assumes it is this which will win us the spiritual gold medals. It may have a short term effect (convincing us of the rightness of our decisions), but it is neither godly nor wise and we must be clear on this at least.

General
Enquiries

enquiries@proctrust.org.uk

Tel: 020 7407 0561

Conference Enquiries

conferences@proctrust.org.uk

Tel: 020 7407 0569

Cornhill Training Current Enquiries

cornhill@proctrust.org.uk

Tel: 020 7407 0562

Cornhill Training Course Admissions

cornhill.admissions@proctrust.org.uk

Tel: 030 030 23450

Postal address for all correspondence:

116-118 Walworth Road, London SE17 1JL

Click to view our privacy and data protection policy, our privacy and data protection policy for Cornhill students, and our safeguarding policy.