Proclaimer Blog
New hymn misses the mark. Sadly.
Some hymns need updating, musically at least. And I am always cheered when groups who otherwise concentrate on modern songs try their best to revive a modern hymn. So I was mostly cheered the other day to sing Hillsong's Cornerstone (listen here and sheet music here). But I have two objections:
- one is musical. The song starts low so it can up the ante and sing an octave higher later on. I dislike this because most people can't sing a top F anyway and also it is the kind of device which is easy to use to whip people up. I guess you could sing the whole thing in a more moderate key.
- one is theological. The original hymn is about the security of standing on solid ground, not sinking sand. Indeed, this was the first idea that came to Strict and Particular Baptist pastor (and hymn writer) Edward Mote. It came into his head as "I went up Holborn." To replace it with the idea of Cornerstone (a good idea, of course, but a mixed metaphor in this context), seems a great shame. The hymn is diminished for its omission. I guess we could rewrite the chorus:
Christ alone, Solid Ground
Weak made strong in the Saviour's love
Through the storm, he is Lord, Lord of all.
Better perhaps, but still omits the original sentiment of security being found in Christ and no other – "all other ground is sinking sand".
Oh, and it omits one key verse (which is easily remedied)
His oath, his covenant, his blood
Support me in the o'erwhelming flood
When all around my soul gives way
He then is all my strength and stay.
If anyone wants to suggest ways to improve, I'll happily hear them….